FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Contact: Taylor Carr/ taylor.carr@athleteally.org
Athlete Ally Publishes Open Letter to World Rugby Calling for Update to Transgender Participation Policies
Nearly 375 members of the international rugby community joined Athlete Ally in an effort to make rugby inclusive for transgender athletes.
New York (November 1st, 2017) – Today, Athlete Ally, and nearly 375 members of the international rugby community call on World Rugby to stand with its transgender athletes and immediately adopt the International Olympic Committee’s 2015 policies related to the participation of transgender athletes in the sport.
Current World Rugby policies require transgender athletes to undergo a series of unnecessary, expensive, and sometimes unwanted surgical, medical, and legal barriers just to compete in the sport. The current policy mirrors the 2003 Stockholm Consensus, which the International Olympic Committee has since overturned, stating “to require surgical anatomical changes as a pre-condition to participation is not necessary to preserve fair competition and may be inconsistent with developing legislation and notions of human rights”.
“Sport should be a place of equal access, experience and opportunity, — regardless of gender identity or sexual orientation,” said Hudson Taylor, founder and executive director of Athlete Ally. “Current World Rugby policies do little but demean and exclude an entire group of athletes who wish to participate in the sport they love.”
Across the world, other sports federations have created affirmative policies for transgender athletes, and there has never been a reported case of these guidelines causing harm or being abused. Organizations such as the International Swimming Federation, World Archery, World Curling Federation, World Badminton Federation, and the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) have adopted policies that mirror the International Olympic Committee’s 2015 consensus guidelines. These updated policies allow athletes to play on the team consistent with their gender identity, given their hormone levels are within the established equitable range of the gender in which they wish to compete as.
The current outdated World Rugby policies are having detrimental consequences on transgender athletes around the world. Athletes like Jean Kim, a Fordham University student and transgender female whose life was literally saved when she found rugby. Now, she’s barred from officially competing. Today, Jean has partnered with Athlete Ally to tell her story, and ask Rugby’s governing body to accept and include her in the sport she loves.
“At one of the darkest moments of my life, Rugby at Fordham provided me with a community and family that gave me the hope to live,” said Jean Kim, a transgender rugby player at Fordham University. “Today, I partner with Athlete Ally in an effort to ensure that transgender rugby players around the world are able play the sport they love, and aren’t excluded for the sole reason of living their authentic life.”
Until World Rugby aligns with the International Olympic Committee’s 2015 guidelines, transgender athletes around the world will miss out on experiencing the joys of rugby. The global community this sport impacts deserves to play this sport authentically, wholeheartedly, and without fear of discrimination.
The open Letter reads as follows:
Dear World Rugby,
We the undersigned members of the athletic community call on World Rugby to stand with its transgender athletes and immediately adopt the International Olympic Committee’s 2015 Policies[1] related to the participation of transgender athletes in the sport.
World Rugby’s mission, vision, and values are ideals we share. We too believe in the core values of integrity, respect, solidarity, passion, and discipline. It’s because of those shared values that we write to you today. Due to your current policies pertaining to transgender athletes, World Rugby is failing to live up to these values, and is failing to lead its community. You are shutting the door on skilled athletes and talented coaches. You’ve created an atmosphere that excludes an entire community of willing participants – and that’s not the culture we envision World Rugby leading.
Current World Rugby policies require transgender athletes to undergo a series of unnecessary, expensive, and sometimes unwanted surgical, medical, and legal barriers just to compete in the sport that they love[2]. The current policy mirrors the 2003 Stockholm Consensus, which the International Olympic Committee has since overturned, stating “to require surgical anatomical changes as a pre-condition to participation is not necessary to preserve fair competition and may be inconsistent with developing legislation and notions of human rights”.[3]
World Rugby policies are built on principles that claim it is “A Sport For All” and a sport built on principles such as “Respect”[4]. Requiring athletes to choose between their gender identity and their sport is counter to everything for which sport stands. This is discrimination, but it can easily be remedied.
Sports federations have already created affirmative policies for transgender athletes, and there has never been a reported case of these guidelines causing harm or being abused. Organizations such as the International Swimming Federation, World Archery, World Curling Federation, World Badminton Federation, and the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) have adopted policies that mirror the International Olympic Committee’s 2015 consensus guidelines. These updated policies allow athletes to play on the team consistent with their gender identity, given their hormone levels are within the established equitable range of the gender in which they wish to compete as.
Until World Rugby aligns with the International Olympic Committee’s 2015 guidelines, transgender athletes around the world will miss out on experiencing the joys of rugby. We respectfully request that World Rugby immediately update their policy for transgender athletes, and align themselves with the 2015 IOC Consensus. Transgender athletes can’t wait and neither can the sport of rugby. The global community this sport impacts deserves to play this sport authentically, wholeheartedly, and without fear of discrimination.
Sincerely,
- Jean Kim, New York Rugby Club
- Kate Byrne, The Village Lions RFC
- Victoria Wheeler, Sam Houston State University club women’s rugby
- Evi Ashenbrucker, New York Rugby Club (player), KIPP NYC High School Boys (coach)
- Caroline Scott, Tulane University Women
- Angela Corpus, Village Lions – play; Fordham Women’s Rugby – coach
- Erika Kocher, Village Liins RFC
- Molly Root, Boulder Babes Rugby
- Paige Bramblett, College of Charleston’s Women’s Rugby Club
- Stephanie Fisher, San Antonio Riveters (player), BASIS San Antonio North Central (coach)
- Kristin Raphel
- Sarah Vlasak
- Lindsay Clifford , SJFC
- Yoshi Shapiro, NYRC
- Ashley Gilbert
- Brianne Gilbert
- Gabriella Rivera, University of New Mexico
- Emily Magee, NYRC: player, PLAY RUGBY: coach
- Theresa Cassano, Village Lions
- Robin Foss, SLO Beaches
- Sara Dechance, San Luis Obispo Women’s Rugby
- Alanna Shelley, San Luis Obispo Women’s Rugby
- Allison Brombach, University of Alabama WRFC
- Meagan Blocker, Central Michigan Women’s Rugby
- Emmarie Etheridge, Village Lions
- Julianna Wiggins
- Julia Lisi, Carleton College Women’s Rugby
- Sara Almidany, Women’s rugby UNM
- Jessica Premet, USF women’s rugby coach and Tampa Krewe women’s rugby player
- Taiana Ospina
- Helen Moser, New York City
- Erika Granger, New York Rugby Club
- Ingrid Lyons
- Yesenia Negron, Union Rugby
- Shannon McNamara , Minnesota Valkyries Rugby Club
- Alessandra Youth, Fordham University
- Melanie Pastuck, New York Rugby Club
- Nathan Lee, San antonio womens – the riveters
- Shashana Markus, SFGG Rugby
- Megan Banford, Village Lions RFC
- Gissela Van, The Village Lions
- Jessica Isaacs, Circle City Tempests
- Holly Cuozzo, San Antonio Riveters
- Michelle Kwandham, San Antonio women’s rugby
- Sierra Cutler, Village Lions RFC
- Aurora Conry, Illiana Screaming Banshees
- Christina Kukla , Illiana Banshees
- Abigail Froelich , Illiana Banshees
- Stephen McAllister, NYC Touch
- Nick Spade, Fort Wayne Women’s Rugby
- Casey McCullough, SLO Women’s Rugby
- TG (Brittany) Tietje, Youngstown Steel Valley Rugby Club, women’s team
- Maggie Mouratides, Illiana Rugby – Banshees
- Brandalyn Watts, D2 Atlanta Harlequins
- Julie Ngo, University of New Mexico
- Paiton daniel, Illiana Banshees
- Yesenia Herrera, Illiana Banshees
- Shannon Steelman , Rowan University, Colby College
- Precious Cummings , New York Rugby
- Essence “Chip” Bell, Ohio Elite, W1823, Scioto Valley, Tiffin Univ., Stars Rugby 7s
- Kate Newton, San Luis Obispo Women’s Rugby Team
- Jess Lee, SA Womens – The Riveters
- Rico Garcia, Village Lions
- Cara Goad, Chicago Women’s Rugby
- Andrea Villanova, New York Rugby Club
- Kerry Conlin, New York Rugby Club
- Katherine Ailshire, no team affiliation
- Hailey Billitier, Village Lions
- Emily Hsieh, USA Rugby Referee, Brown University, Beantown
- Brit Fryer, Gotham Knights
- Shelby Veazey, Princeton Athletic Club
- Jenna Wertz, Budd Bay Bandits
- Kayla Adderley, Western Washington University Women’s Rugby, St. Paul’s Academy
- Desiree Williams, Play for the Budd Bay Bandits, coach Budd Bay Steelheads
- Abby Rios, County Will Morrigans
- Dasante Browne, University of New Mexico
- Ezra wagoner, Chuckanut Bay rugby
- Maggie McLaughlin, Budd Bay Bandits Rugby
- Jenn Hightower, Norfolk Storm
- Caitria Sands, Quinnipiac Women’s Rugby
- Noel keyes, Chuckanut Bay Rugby
- Cassandra Schultz, Winona State Black Katy’s
- Sydnie Lee, Chuckanut Bay Rugby Club
- Meaghan Stuke, Budd bay bandits
- Alexis Howell, Emerald City Mudhens
- Abigail Cook, Quinnipiac
- Laura Boccadoro, Darien high school club sport
- Richard Gallina, Play & Organizational President
- Javier Sanz, Village lions
- Anna Harootunian, no team affiliation
- Kim Benigsohn, no team affiliation
- Keith Friedlander, Village Lions
- Racheal Pederson, Chuckanut Bay Rugby Mussels
- Liz McSpedon2, no team affiliation
- Kristen Guernier, Village lions
- Francois Fay, Village Lions RFC
- JJ Darling, Village Lions
- Lena Silberman, Cal poly women’s rugby team
- Morgan Moulis, SLO Beaches
- Kelly Brown, St. Louis Sabres Women’s Rugby
- Lena Ezell, St. Louis Sabres
- Jack Holtzman, St. Louis Sabres Rugby Football Club
- Sarah Newton, Sabres St. Louis Womens Rugby Club
- Elizabeth Crotty, St. Louis Sabres
- Shelby Lin, NYRC
- Blossom Booth, Carleton College
- Sradha Patel, University of New Mexico Women’s Rugby
- Kayla Potter, STL Sabres
- Elijah Lacap, SFU Rugby
- Eli Morrow
- Joe D
- Luke De Gregorio
- Jamie King, HSU Jacks
- Mary Haedrich, Fordham
- Sarah Barber, Nashville Women’s Rugby Football Club (Stone Lions)
- Alexis Laraway, Former Collegiate Rugby Player
- Calvin Terris
- Sarah Bogdan, Village Lions
- Sarah Minahan, NYRC
- Katarzyna Laczny, SFU Rugby
- Vanessa Ryan, Fordham women’s rugby club
- Skylar Neil, NYRC
- Rowe Galt
- Nancy Scuri, NYRC
- Emily Cronin, Rochester Renegades
- Illeen Diplan, Brockport badgers
- Amanda Miller, Rochester Renegades
- Vivian Smith, Fox valley vixens wrfc
- Lauren Patterson, Bay Area Rugby Club
- Darian Hallbauer, University of New Mexico
- Patricia Adams, Fresno State Women’s Rugby
- Elizabeth Kirkman, Budd Bay Bandits
- Riley Bradford, ADFA Rugby Club, ACT, Australia
- Rachel Valdez, Play San Antonio women’s
- Victoria Spencer, Louisville Women’s Rugby Club
- Abbie Oswalt, Kansas Bison
- Ben Wagner, Lawrence Bison
- Bianka Martinez, UIC Rugby
- Janie Sparks, Kansas women’s Jayhawks Rugby and the Kansas City Roller Warriors
- Rebecca Haight, Quinnipiac
- Jennifer Robles, NIU
- Codi Fletcher, SUNY Plattsburgh
- Yejadai Dunn, Beantown
- Kasch Meier, Smith College
- Amanda Fins, Union county women’s rugby club
- Paige Gallagher, Union county women’s rugby club
- Mara Friedman, Rutgers women’s rugby
- Tia Thompson, Hawaii Titahz
- Angela Corpus, Play – Village Lions RFC; Coach – Fordham University Women’s Rugby
- Ashley Barranzuela, Union County Women’s Rugby
- Nicole Myers, Swilers Rugby
- Cassie Kennedy, Newfoundland Rugby
- Jacqueline Silva
- Raichle Johnson, Rutland Rugby Club/University of Maine at Farmington
- Taylor LeFevre, Rutland Women’s Rugby
- Sarah Weinman, Rutgers University Women’s ice hockey
- Caroline Lucy, Fordham Women’s Club Rugby
- Lauren C, Monadnock Wolfpack RFC
- James Johnston, Village Lions
- Stephanie Diu, Princeton University and Village Lions
- Hannah Rash
- Denisse Zambon, Old Blue, Norwich University
- Bryn Friedenberg, Penn Women’s Club Rugby
- Lis Gallant
- Barbara Pennington, Rutland Rugby Club
- Kai Zook
- Elizabeth Peralta-Reed
- Adesuwa Wilson-Iguade, Rutgers Women’s Rowing
- Coryelle Pondy, Yale University
- Stephanie Greenlaw, Dallas Harlequins
- Dylan Jacobs, Santa Barbara Rugby Academy
- Eugene Aiken, Village Lions RFC
- Tiara Mack, Providence Rugby
- Tosan Tutse-Tonwe, Viral Rugby
- Alexis Thompson, UPenn Women’s Rugby, Phoenixville Women’s Rugby
- Catherine Nacier, Brown University
- Emma Gallagher, Swilers RFC
- Gabriella Moore
- Taisha Vargas, Western Connecticut State University Women’s Rugby
- Ari Ray, Village Lions RFC
- Emma Gardiner, Baydogs
- Tracy Hawkins, Mount College girls rugby, Papamoa Bulldogs, Ngongotaha Netball
- Hannah Frank, University of Pennsylvania Women’s Rugby
- Jenn Hightower, Norfolk Storm
- Arielle Thomas
- Ruth Phelps, Purdue University Women’s Rugby
- Mason Johnson, Quinnipiac
- Jay McFadden, Purdue Women’s Rugby
- Kirstin Kulich, New Zealand All Blacks
- Tristan Pickett
- Christina Henderson, Rutland Ravens Rugby
- Abby Moon, Purdue Rugby
- Christine Thomas, Purdue Women’s Rugby club
- Kate Brady, Purdue Women’s Rugby club
- Corina Hendren, Union Mudturtles
- Michelle Jones, Yale Women’s Rugby
- Angela Henderson, YWRFC
- Kelsey Morgan, NL ROCK RUBGY / Swiler club
- Khristina Hanchett, Betterside Women’s rugby
- Nick Lyons
- Zach Sutton
- Cameron Fear, Brandeis women’s and Needham high school girls
- Willie Cabral, Nashville Grizzlies
- Heath Martin, Oregon Sports Union (ORSU)
- JJ Darling, Village Lions
- Avery Salermo, Union County Women’s Rugby
- Nick Literski
- Kylie Tito, Waimana
- Linsey Organ, San Luis Obispo Women’s Rugby Club
- Ian Chaplin, Brighton & Hove Sea Serpents RFC
- John Deptford, Liverpool Tritons RUFC
- Simon Clark, Liverpool Tritons
- Thomas Moorhen, Liverpool Tritons
- Jonathan Price, Liverpool Tritons
- Dara Squires, Dog’s Rugby
- Kiana Edmond, Charleston Hurricanes
- Chloe Anderson, UCSC banana slugs
- Jennifer Cortez, Union County Women’s Rugby
- Carl Williams, Cardiff Lions RFC
- Anthony Policastro, RPI ’09-14
- David Clarke, Gotham Knights RFC
- Robert Greenawalt, Village Lions RFC
- Rachel Perler, Yale Women’s Rugby
- Carl Williams, Cardiff Lions RFC
- Jo Hayes, Village Lions
- Ryan Neill, Gotham Knights
- Robert Greenawalt, Village Lions
- K. Amaro, San Fernando Valley
- Lewis Barnes, Gotham Knights
- Alison Berk, Charleston Hurricanes
- Pia Kahle, Rugby Welfen Braunschweig
- Kofi Opam, Philadelphia Gryphons
- Holly Dollimont, Newfoundland U18 team
- Kayla Halleran, Newfoundland U18 team
- Ann-Kathrin Kirschner, Göttingen (GER)
- Kimiora Ngatai, Rangataua Rugby
- Chris Collins, Washington Renegades RFC
- Michael Foley, Seattle Quake RFC.
- Jenna Mega, Danbury Rugby
- Sofia Rudin, Brown University
- Grace Hanson, Budd Bay
- Valerie Bank, Seattle Saracens
- Hannah Johnson, Seattle Saracens
- Venice Wong, Used to play for the Seattle Breakers
- Meghan Childs, Baymen Rugby & HSH Rugby
- Kelly Lyon
- Michael Kengmana, Gotham Knights
- Nicole Carroll, Monmouth Renegades
- Magnus Borsini
- Kara Morgan, Indianapolis women’s rugby football club(Hoydens)
- Katherine Henry, Beantown Rugby
- Nathan Colom, Dunfermline RFC/ Manchester Village Spartans RFC
- Patrick Button, Crescent City Rougaroux RFC
- Russell Kingaby, Brighton and Hove Sea Serpents RFC
- Michael Donatz, Gotham Knights RFC
- Adam Wide, President- the Berlin Bruisers RFC
- Erik Schoonhoven, ARC Amsterdam Lowlanders
- Nina Corda, Union60 Bremen Rugby
- Sophie Brakemeier, Rugby Union Marburg
- Mikel Aristegui, Berlin Bruisers
- Leighton Cheal, Berlin Bruisers RFC
- Frederic von Verschuer, Berlin Bruisers
- Colin Comfort, Berlin Bruisers RFC
- Guillaume Carpentier, Berlin Bruisers RFC
- Guillermo Aguilar, Berlin Bruisers
- Dries Vanelstlande, Straffe Ketten RFC
- Alexander Panasuk, Berlin Bruisers
- Josh Sanders, Berlin Bruisers RFC
- Christopher Moore, Berlin Sports Club Rugby
- Amanda Parker, Fordham women’s
- Monica VanBuskirk, Glendale Raptors
- Alice Plant, Atlanta Harlequins
- Liz Berridge, Village Lions Women
- Lola Hourihane, Yale Women’s Rugby
- Kerry Shields, Fordham University
- Oliver Samuels, DRFC
- Mike Geibel, Eckerd College
- Haylie Samsrl, Referee
- Sabrina White, Fordham University
- Jessica Kurtz
- David Achilles, Columbus Kodiaks RFC
- Eni Katrini, Fordham University
- Adam Falk
- Lauren Baron, Penn women’s rugby football club
- Claire Rhee, Alumna of Brown University
- Alan Silver, Lumberjacks
- Kevin Rohde, Lumberjacks
- Kieran Holohan, Village Lions
- Helix Holman, Lumberjacks
- Orla maclean, Cornell University
- Robin Kaluzniak
- Mike Patterson, Markham Irish Canadians
- Steve Darnell, University of South Carolina Rugby
- Lilith South, UGA Women’s Rugby Football Club
- Katie Peterson, UGA Women’s Rugby Football Club
- Mary Howard, UGA Women’s Rugby Football Club
- Jennifer Barto, UGA Women’s Rugby Football Club
- Lee chapman, Bend Lady Roughriders
- Margaret Pierce, UGA Women’s Rugby Football Club
- Mackenzie Doolittle , Chicago Dragons Rugby Football Club
- Rachel Wright, University of Surrey
- Michael Cohen, Washington Renegades RFC
- Emma Noble, Gotham Girls Roller Derby
- David Zimmerman, Elgin River Rats, Larkin H.S.
- Richard Every, USA Rugby
- Casey Morrison, Champlain college
- Natasha Lesnefsky, Nashville Women’s Rugby Football Club
- Leann Bauer, Morris Rugby
- Lindsey Stanek, Tulane Women’s Rugby
- Jackie White, ORSU Rugby
- Amanda Gargano, Danbury Women’s Rugby
- Shelby Abdilah, DC Furies
- Annie Rumler, Columbia Bombshells Women’s Rugby
- Kay Wilson, Columbia Bombshells Women’s Rugby
- Alison Berk, Charleston Hurricanes Women’s Rugby/ Charleston Youth Rugby
- Jordyn Ashlock, West Linn Rugby
- Hannah Hoover, Tulane University Women’s Rugby
- Katherine Bitgood, Morris Women’s Rugby (NJ)
- Avery Johnson, ORSU Rugby
- Jacob Wingert, Milwaukee Rugby Football Club
- Amanda Brower, Monmouth Women’s Rugby
- Beth Kaltenbach, Monmouth Women’s Rugby
- Sian Parker, Monmouth Women’s Rugby
- Ivy, Monmouth Women’s Rugby
- Kate Benedit, Monmouth Women’s Rugby
- Rayne Trouwborst, Monmouth Women’s Rugby
- Meagan Donovan, Monmouth
- Srob Oberman-Breindel, New York Rugby Club
- Maria Guerra, Union County Women’s Rugby
- Gabriela Mobtoya
- Victoria Steele, Union County Women’s Rugby
- Chloe Giannone, Monmouth Rugby
- Nicole lamparelli, Fairfield Yankees Rugby
- Angela Francisck, Fairfield Yankees Rugby
- Yeny Olivas, Fairfield Yankees Rugby
- Kimberly Semiglia, Old Blue Womens Rugby
- Corinne Heavner, Old Blue/Penn State
- Francesca Sands, Old Blue and Dartmouth
- Caitria Sands, Old Blue Womens Rugby
- Sarah Buonopans, Old Blue Womens Rugby
- Katherine Ramage, Old Blue Womens Rugby
- Gabriella Cantorna, Old Blue Womens Rugby
- Bernard Cantorna, State College HS
- Danielle Walko-Siua, Old Blue
- Ladaejah Adams, New York Rugby Club Highschool Girls
- Mahdia Parker, New York Rugby Club
- Shandale Ricketts, New York Rugby Club
- Jennifer Salomon, Old Blue Rugby
- Samantha McGann, New York Rugby Club
- J Branson Brown, Blue Ridge Bootleggers Rugby Football Club
- Angelica Owen, Life University Rugby
- Lauren Dodd, Life University Rugby
- Darian Lovelace, Life University Rugby
- Jessi Purawic, Penn State Rugby
- Robyn Mertz
- Alix Coleman, Penn State Rugby
- Cassie Stockhausen, Downingtown High School Girls Rugby
- Gianna Solomon, Penn State Rugby
- Sofie Mota
- Lucian Jessel
- Madison McCormick, PSU
- Azniv Nalbandian, Penn State
- Margaret Carly, Penn State Rugby
- Alex Weisser, Penn State Rugby
- Emily Barton, Penn State Rugby
- Tara Pieper
- Donna Kinsey
- Emma Cassidy, Fordham University Women’s Rugby
- Katie Sayer, Penn State Rugby
- Brie Barto, Penn State Rugby
- Julie Gould, Ventura County Women’s Rugby Club
- Yoshi Shapiro, New York Rugby Club
- S Gavis-Hughson, Yale Rugby
[1]From IOC Consenus Meeting on Sex Reassignment and Hyperandrogenism, November 2015, https://stillmed.olympic.org/Documents/Commissions_PDFfiles/Medical_commission/2015-11_ioc_consensus_meeting_on_sex_reassignment_and_hyperandrogenism-en.pdf
[2] From World Rugby’s Player Welfare Guide: Gender Identity Disorder and Disorders of Sexual Differentiation Policy, March 2010, http://www.irbplayerwelfare.com/?documentid=1
[3]From IOC Consenus Meeting on Sex Reassignment and Hyperandrogenism, November 2015, https://stillmed.olympic.org/Documents/Commissions_PDFfiles/Medical_commission/2015-11_ioc_consensus_meeting_on_sex_reassignment_and_hyperandrogenism-en.pdf
[4] From the World Rugby Charter, http://laws.worldrugby.org/?charter=3